People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We ordered three pizzas the other night and breadsticks with cheese. Food was ready on time and perfect order. Breadsticks are extremely good ”
“ This place has the best pizza I have ever had delicious can’t say that enough you guys are rocking awesome and kudos to the cook and the ladies working the register on New Year’s Eve night. ... ”
“ I love the salad bar. It’s always clean, well stocked, fresh, and reasonably priced. For less than 7, I can get a large plate of salad. For 10.??, you can get unlimited refills of salad. It’s been a challenge to find a salad bar after everything shut down in 2020. So thankful I found this salad bar. Very clean. Smells fresh. Nice staff. Reasonable prices. It’s my new “go-to” for any meal. P.S. If you eat pizza, they have lots of good pizza. I am gluten free, so I don’t eat pizza, but my family and friends love it!! Lunch pizza buffet is also very reasonably priced. ”
“ Food is spectacular! I ordered The Chicago Fire on crispy crust, and it was so delicious. It was just spicy enough once I added some red pepper flakes. The service is excellent, and the salad bar was fresh and clean! I am very impressed and will be back! Sorry, no pictures, we were hungry! ”
“ I ordered pizza and breadsticks for dinner. It was really good! We love the Magnificent Mile pizza. They always have tasty, hot pizzas that are made quickly. Always wonderful service as well! ”
“ What an unexpected surprise. We went here because we heard they had a salad bar. When we showed up, they also had a huge pizza buffet as well. It was 12 for the pizza buffet, salad bar and a beverage. There we were twelve pizzas on the buffet and the salad bar had lots of choices. They also had breadsticks which were also very good. They constantly refilled the pizzas that were out. They even had a deep dish pizza on the buffet. I highly recommend this place for lunch. ”
“ My family has been wanting to try their buffet for a while but we keep a strict diet 99% of the time and the buffet has limited lunch hours. We were not disappointed at all! The pizza was great, I liked the drink options for sugar free choices. The toppings are under the cheese and my wife did get a pizza with onions in it. She doesn't like onions. I ate the cheese off those slices and set them aside cause I don't like onions either. When they came around to collect the plates, the staff said nothing about the two partial eaten slices. They smiled and grabbed our plates just the same. No big deal. Overall we really enjoyed the pizza and we felt like it was a great value. We will be back for sure! In like a month or two when we finally have a cheat meal lol. Thanks Chicago's! ”
“ Very good pizza and pasta! Our server was friendly and doing her best on a very busy night. The restaurant is very clean and well maintained. Also a great partner to local places with their fundraising opportunities. Very accommodating for a book club as well. ”
Menu
Classic Ham & Cheese
US$8.33BBQ Chicken Pizza (Deep Dish)
US$21.391-Topping Crispy Crust (Large)
US$18.681 Topping Traditional Crust (Small)
US$10.921 Topping Traditional Crust (Medium)
US$14.37
About
Chicago's Pizza Columbus
Welcome to Chicago's Pizza Columbus, a gem nestled in the heart of Columbus, Indiana, where the rich flavors of Chicago-style pizza come alive. Located at 3780 W Jonathan Moore Pike, this establishment has quickly become a favored spot for both locals and visitors, serving up delicious pies that transport you straight to the Windy City.
At Chicago's Pizza Columbus, the emphasis lies on quality and flavor. Their all-day specialty pizzas are a true testament to that commitment. Whether you crave the fiery kick of the Chicago Fire—topped with pepperoni, jalapeños, and a spicy buffalo drizzle—or the classic combination of sweet ham and pineapple from the Hawaiian, there’s something that will tickle your taste buds.
- The Big Hurt: This pizza boasts both pepperoni and chopped pepperoni for a hearty delight at only $11.96.
- Windy City: Savor the flavors of Italian sausage, green pepper, and onions for $12.99.
- BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger: A unique twist with BBQ sauce, beef, onion, bacon, and cheddar cheese for $15. You can customize it with pickles for that full burger experience!
For those with dietary preferences, Chicago's Pizza Columbus also offers gluten-free and cauliflower crust options starting at $15.81. Their deep-dish pizzas are not to be missed, with prices ranging from $17.42 to $18.74, perfect for indulgent sharing. Each pie is crafted with fresh ingredients, honoring the deep-rooted traditions of Chicago pizza.
The ambiance exudes warmth and friendliness, complemented by a highly praised salad bar that receives rave reviews. As one enthusiastic customer pointed out, you can enjoy a large plate of salad for less than $7, or opt for unlimited refills at just $10. Such value amidst the culinary delights makes it a go-to lunch spot!
Chicago's Pizza Columbus has garnered high praise from its patrons, with comments highlighting prompt service and quality food. One satisfied customer, Teri Bogard, remarked on the spectacular flavors of The Chicago Fire pizza, while others enjoyed the efficiency and warmth of the staff, making every visit memorable.
In conclusion, Chicago's Pizza Columbus is not just a place to grab a meal; it’s an experience that emphasizes community, quality, and the joy of good food. Whether craving a slice of classic Chicago-style pizza or a fresh salad, this venue is sure to become a favorite for many. Call them today at +1 812-657-7003 and indulge in a slice of Chicago right here in Indiana!
Book a table